Tuesday, March 11, 2008

What Would Tammy Do?

Huh. So Eliot Spitzer, current Governor and former Attorney General of New York who built his political reputation by targeting Wall Street corruption and ethically dubious business practices by the likes of Merrill Lynch and Sony BMG, was busted by federal authorities investigating a "high end" prostitution ring. Many media outlets are noting that his has the potential to be a career-ending scandal for Spitzer, while other commentators observe the irony in Spitzer being, well, "Spitzered" -- that is, targeted by the type of criminal investigation with which his name became synonymous.

Clearly, politicians' involvement in sex scandals is nothing new*: Republicans and Democrats. Local, state, and federal officials. Gay and straight. Young and old. Sex scandals have marred the careers of a wide variety of politicians. One thing these men do seem to have in common, however, is having staid, supportive spouses who take Tammy's advice and "stand by their man". Hillary Clinton. Suzanne Craig. Wendy Vitter. Carlita Kilpatrick. And now Silda Spitzer. All have stood resolutely alongside their shamed husbands, hands clasped and heads bowed solemnly while their partners ask public forgiveness for their transgressions.

I have been thinking a lot about this and have decided that the wives of publicly disgraced politicians are in similar situations as battered women. After all, both groups of women have partners who engage in morally reprehensible behavior that causes them pain, shame, and embarrassment, and both groups of women generally are expected to simply pick up and leave their husbands. Yet, I'd wager that the decision to leave one's publicly shamed politician husband is just as agonizing as the decision to leave one's abusive husband. (One crucial difference, though: politicians' wives obviously do not face the economic challenges that many battered women do.) Consider the words of Dina McGreevey, ex-wife of former New Jersey governor James McGreevey who was embroiled in a sex scandal of his own back in 2004:

"I was criticized for standing there. Hillary Clinton was criticized for standing there with her husband. We all do it for very personal reasons," McGreevey said in the CNN interview.

"You don't know what it's like unless you're in the person's shoes."

Agreed, and I think that sentiment applies equally well to women in abusive relationships. That said, I will allow that -- just once -- it would be incredibly refreshing for the wife of one of these politicians to hold a press conference in which she announced that she was kicking his [cheating/lying/philandering/adultering/prostituting/etc.] scoundrel ass to the curb.

*Though such news undoubtedly is more shocking when the politician is (or, more accurately, was) regarded as an uncompromising moral crusader like Spitzer.

9 comments:

Velma said...

Thanks for the post. I thought the same thing when I saw the press conference. For the record, I informed hubby that I am not the kind of girl that would stand by my man on TV. At the same time, political families have spent years polishing their 'front stage' behaviors, and I think it is hard to break out of this mold.

ShockProf said...

Dina McG was on the Today show, uh... today (that sounds weird). I'd like to go back and watch her interview again with Matt Lauer, since the kids were running around and I couldn't really hear it.

She is certainly in a league of her own, given that her husband had to admit to not only having an affair, but being a "gay American" to boot. I think she was mostly in shock during that first press conference. Too creepy...

newsocprof said...

yes, that would be refreshing...

i'm actually less surprised when it involves an 'uncompromising moral crusader' -- fits better with crim theory that suggests deviance is the norm, right?

Dr. Huginkiss said...

Good point, newsocprof. Control theorists, unite!

BTW, here is the CNN interview with Dina McGreevey.

Velma said...

Welcome newsocprof. I think it is maternal smoking or low self control. Seriously, in our time of moral panic over sex crimes, I hope that events like this raise our understanding of the pervasiveness of sex-related criminal behavior. In addition, I am happy to see another example of where we sanctioned the john.

newsocprof said...

i agree -- it's nice to see sanctions against the john as well.

the symbolic interactionist in me (in addition to the criminologist) is similarly fascinated by all this. the law and order types, like Spitzer, seem to never see the danger in "too much" control -- perhaps he understands this a bit more now.

Scooby said...

I think the abused-woman analogy is off base. This woman has lots of options - being married to a billionaire helps. Crazy thought.... Maybe she loves him and is having an impossible time coming to terms with the fact that her whole world is caving in around her? Imagine the web of lies that this animal weaved. I can't imagine how much out of nowhere this must have come to her.

Dr. Huginkiss said...

I hear what you're sayin', Scoob, and I totally agree that politicians' wives have infinitely more resources at their disposal than the typical woman trying to leave her abusive partner. But, at the same time, "Maybe she loves him and is having an impossible time coming to terms with the fact that her whole world is caving in around her" is a statement that, in my view, is equally applicable to battered women. In fact, the women I have interviewed frequently express this very sentiment -- the realization that they must leave the partner they love (and often the father of their children) is devastating to them. I don't think it's a perfect analogy by any means, but I think there are some parallels there...

Scooby said...

Not trying to split hairs - but that is a problem. I find it unhelpful to group general pressures to keep a marriage going and a general tendency to feel "trap" in a marriage with anything even close to what battered women go through. In a serious moment - we are all "trapped" to some degree in a marriage. that is what helps us weather the tough times, knowing that should we stick out the troubled times. There is something very distinct about battered woman syndrome.